Lobster 101: How to Cook Lobster Perfectly Every Time

Learn how to cook lobster perfectly with our easy-to-follow instructions. Get tips on selecting your lobster, the best cooking techniques, and serving suggestions to make your meal successful.

Jump to Recipe

Lobster is a popular seafood delicacy enjoyed by many people around the world, but you don’t need to be a chef to cook it properly. To cook a lobster like a pro, you must first understand some basic facts.

It’s important to note that there are different types of lobsters. Cold-water Maine lobster is the most common type in North America, while the spiny lobster (rock lobster) of warmer waters is also available. New England is well-known for its fresh Maine lobsters while spiny lobsters are what you’ll find in the warmer waters of the Southeastern United States.

You also want to handle live lobsters carefully, as they can pinch very hard. Markets sell them with bands on the claws to prevent people from getting pinched.

The most common way to cook live lobsters is to boil them in a pot of salted water until the shell turns bright red.

Many prefer serving it with melted butter or dipping sauces like garlic butter or cocktail sauce. And no one will say no to a loaf of crusty no-knead bread on the side.

Whether you’re grilling, baking, steaming, or boiling your lobster, following these basics will ensure great results.

Lobster Selection

When selecting the perfect lobster, there are several factors to consider. First and foremost, it’s important to choose a fresh live lobster. Fresh lobsters will have lively tails and claws that move when touched or picked up. You should also check that the tail and claws are intact and firm.

When buying live lobsters, choose those that feel heavy for their size and show signs of life, like moving their antennae, tail, or legs.

If you’re not cooking them immediately after purchase, store them in a cool place with damp newspaper or seaweed on top of the ice to keep them moist.

Another factor to consider when selecting your lobster is size. Larger lobsters yield more meat, but smaller ones can also be delicious and more affordable. It’s also important not to overlook the claw size; larger claws typically contain more meat than smaller ones.

Lastly, consider where you’re getting your lobsters from. Purchase lobsters directly from local fishermen or fish markets rather than grocery stores to get the freshest.

Keep these tips in mind when selecting your lobster for an unforgettable meal.

Preparing Lobster for Cooking

It’s essential to keep the lobster alive right before cooking. Bacteria spreads quickly through the body of a lobster after it dies and isn’t killed during the cooking process. Eating lobster meat contaminated with bacteria is likely to cause food poisoning.

Use a sharp knife or kitchen shears to carefully remove the rubber bands around the claws while holding the lobster firmly around its back. The material the bands are made of isn’t always safe to cook and can alter the taste of the lobster meat.

If you’d rather not handle an active lobster, placing lobsters in the freezer for five to 10 minutes will sedate them and dull their senses. That way, you can kill each lobster humanely before cooking by placing it on a cutting board with its belly down and plunging a sharp broad knife between the first joint and the eyes to split the head in half.

Boiling

For boiling, fill a large pot with water and bring the water to a rolling boil. Add salt and seafood seasoning if desired. Once the water has reached a boil, carefully add the lobsters, head first, one at a time, using tongs or gloves. Once you have the lobsters in the pot, cover most of the top to bring the water back to a boil quickly.

Once your water is boiling again, cover the pot and set your timer. Boil for seven to 10 minutes for one- to 2-pound lobsters, or up to 20 minutes for larger ones. A general rule of thumb for boiling lobsters is seven minutes for the first pound and three minutes for each additional pound.

The meat is usually fully cooked once the shell has turned bright red. If unsure, you can use a meat thermometer to check that it’s reached 135°F (57°C).

Grilling

Before you grill lobster, you must kill it first. The best way to do this is by numbing it in the freezer and slicing its head in half from the back. Once killed, you can grill the whole lobster or cut it in half. If halved, you can also remove any unwanted parts, such as the tomalley (green liver) or roe (eggs), before cooking.

If you are cooking lobster halves, brush olive oil or melted butter on the flesh side of the lobster and place them on a preheated grill with high heat, flesh side down first. Grill for five to seven minutes per side until the meat is opaque and firm.

Always start with a clean grill before cooking.

“If you’re planning on broiling or grilling halved lobsters. A tip for beginners that will minimize the chances of overcooking the lobster meat is to parboil the lobsters before prepping them. Parboiling the lobsters will help the center cook before the outer layer of the meat overcooks from the intense heat of broiling and grilling.”

 — Jack Slobodian, JackSlobodian.com

Baking

Baking is a great way to prepare lobster, especially if you want a healthier cooking method that requires no added fat.

To bake lobster:

1. Start by preheating your oven to 375°F.
2. Cut the lobster in half lengthwise and remove the tomalley and roe if desired.
3. Brush the flesh with melted butter or olive oil and season with salt and pepper.

Place the lobster halves on a baking sheet, shell side down, and bake until the meat is cooked.

The cooking time for a halved lobster will vary depending on the size of the lobster. For a one-pound lobster, cook for 12 to 15 minutes. For a two-pound lobster, cook for 18 to 20 minutes. For a three-pound lobster, cook for 24 to 26 minutes.

You can check if the lobster is cooked through by inserting a meat thermometer into the thickest part of the tail meat. The lobster is done when the internal temperature reaches 135°F.

To add flavor before baking, try stuffing the lobster tail with breadcrumbs mixed with garlic, parsley, lemon zest, and parmesan cheese. Adding other ingredients like chopped shrimp or scallops to this mixture will make an even more luxurious meal perfect for Mother’s Day dinner or other special occasions.

“Keep your seasoning simple. Lobster meat is sweet and buttery on its own, so you don’t want to cover the meat with too many different spices. Less is more here. A little salt and pepper on the tail meat with a lemon-garlic butter on the side is perfection.” 

— Amanda McGrory-Dixon, Burrata and Bubbles

Steaming

Steaming is one of the best ways to cook lobster; it allows even cooking without sacrificing tenderness or flavor.

To steam a lobster, you will need a large pot with a steamer insert and enough water to cover the bottom of the pot by about an inch.

Bring the water to a boil over high heat before placing the lobsters in the steamer basket and covering them with a lid.

Cooking times for steamed lobsters vary depending on their size. A good rule of thumb is to cook them for 10 to 12 minutes per pound, so if you have two one-and-a-half–pound lobsters, they will take around 15 to 18 minutes.

It’s important not to overcook your lobsters, as this can result in tough meat that’s difficult to chew.

When your lobsters are done cooking, remove them from the pot using tongs and let them cool slightly before cracking open their shells and enjoying their succulent meat.

Cooking Tips

To ensure your lobster meat comes out the best every time, follow these tips:

• Choose a live lobster that’s fresh and healthy. Look for lobsters that are active and have all their claws intact.
• The key is not to overcook the meat. Once it turns bright red and opaque, it’s done. Overcooking will result in tough, rubbery meat that will be hard to chew. To ensure you don’t overdo it, set a timer or keep an eye on the clock while cooking.
• Once cooked, remove the lobster from the pot using tongs or a slotted spoon.
• Serve your boiled lobster hot, but let it cool for a few minutes before cracking open its shells with a nutcracker or kitchen shears.

How to Serve Perfectly Cooked Lobster

There’s nothing quite like enjoying a delicious lobster meal for a seafood Friday dinner. The rich and succulent flavor of the meat is hard to resist.

To make it easier to eat, you can use kitchen shears to cut the underside of the tail in half. Then pull the tail meat from the inside so it’s out of the shell. You can also remove the body and head of the lobster and serve only the tail and claw sections.

For a lazy lobster, you can remove the meat completely from the shell before serving your fresh lobster at home. Use a lobster cracker or nutcracker to crack the shell.

Before eating, remove the black intestinal vein that runs through the tail if it wasn’t removed before cooking.

What to Serve with Lobster

The most popular way to serve lobsters is with melted butter and lemon wedges. You can also add dipping sauces like spicy mayonnaise or tiger sauce for a delicious meal that impresses the pickiest eaters.

Cooked lobster meat can be used in soups and salads. It works well in pasta dishes, sandwiches, and countless seafood recipes, too. Try adding it to gumbo or a seafood pot pie.

Why not serve with a side of Ranch style beans, Joanna Gaines green bean casserole, or an exquisite lobster ravioli sauce? No matter how you choose to cook and serve your lobster, remember to savor every bite of this seafood delicacy.

This article originally appeared on Little Bit Recipes.